Skip to main content

The Bureaucracy of Hostages, Day 152.

The third in a five-part series on Michael Wells, a Mississippi man being held hostage in Lebanon (click for link)

by Walker Harris
“Unnatural death always provoked a peculiar unease, an uncomfortable realization that there were still some things that might not be susceptible to bureaucratic control.”
― P.D. James, The Lighthouse
"The government is using every ethical resource at its disposal."  The tall woman portrayed no empathy at all.  Ellen van Oss was was always in control. Her words, her manner, her clothing, her hair. all carefully selected to give the image of control.  Long blonde hair tightly pulled back into a controlled bun, pulling slightly at her temples, as if indirectly controling for wrinkles.  Ms. von Oss's unlined face betrayed no emotion, and her eyes were guarded as she spoke to me.

A member of the press, I was the enemy.

Ellen van Oss has been assigned to the Wells case since those first harrowing days of captivity.  She declines to provide additional details about her involvement in the Wells hostage situation, but the details speak for themselves.

By policy, the US government does not pay ransom demands.  Although the theory behind this decision is solid - any payment to kidnappers could increase the 'demand' for kidnapping victims - the simple fact is that paying ransom works.  A number of pragmatic European countries disavow payments, but 'miraculously' have consistently negotiated for the release of their prisoners.

Clearly, some countries work behind the scenes to provide indirect, in-kind, or incentive payments to secure the release of their prisoners.

And just as clearly, the US government has no interest in doing so.  Ms. van Oss has, over the course of the 152 days of Michael Wells' captivity, failed to prioritize the release of the prisoner.  In fact, research done by this newspaper determined when there were breakthroughs in hostage negotiations in the past two years.

President loses face in G7 summit, Dec.2;  Strike of 'terrorist camp' in Syria, Dec 4.
Presidential approval rating below 50%, Jan 14; Strike of 'terrorist camp' in Lebanon, Jan 16.
President's proposed legislation defeated, Jan 31; Strike of 'terrorist camp' in Oman, Feb 2.

The list continues.  Every time the president needs to look strong and in command, within two days there is a military offensive against a terrorist organization.  No such correlation exists between terrorist kidnapping of Americans and offensives.

Ms. van Oss will not comment on the administration's position on the use of military force to bolster polls.  She also does not comment on whether the back door negotiations - for which she denies the existence - whether they have ever resulted in the release of a single captive.

She refuses to discuss timelines for release.  She refuses to say whether there is any rescue operation planned.  Her only concession to comment related to how unhelpful the press is.

Meanwhile, Michael Wells' family remains in the dark.

It has been 152 days. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Bureaucracy of Hostages, Day 149. (Part 2 in a series)

The second in a five-part series on a Mississippi man being held hostage in Lebanon  (click for link) By Walker Harris This week marks five months that Michael Wells has been held in captivity in Lebanon. Late last year, the Vicksburg native was captured in Beirut and has been held for ransom by a radical extremist group. For the duration of is captivity, his wife, Lainie Wells, has held on to the hope that her husband would be freed - that his time would come.  From her home in the Audubon Hills area of Vicksburg, she described what the ordeal has been like.  "I seldom get any information," she said, "and everyone is doing their job, but it is not making any difference." Lainie has spent her adult life observing nature, and the preternatural stillness that she has developed as a wildlife biologist is on full display during the interview.  As a seasoned journalist, I have to admit that it is a little unnerving to hold a conversation with someone who moves i...

The Bureaucracy of Hostages. Day 146.

By Walker Harris  “Everyone assumes that it's not their place to take direct personal responsibility for what happens; that level of vested individual power is part of the previous almost feudal version of responsibility. The deindividuation is actually to a certain extent the desired outcome, though its negative consequences are not.”  ― Nick H arkaway, The Blind Giant “This government is using every ethical means to bring your husband back to you.” The US State Department employee stared over the shoulder of Vicksburg resident Lainie Wells as she recited the words. Ellen van Oss is a trim, tall, intense woman, wispy blond hair pulled back into a tight bun. Her words are delivered in a staccato manner, perfectly matching the bureaucratic script that she recites.  I watch as Lainie’s jaw tightens, a momentary betrayal of the emotion that she normally keeps under a placid façade. I have watched the interactions between Lainie and Ellen for several months no...